Join ARSA Ask ARSA Pay ARSA

ARSA Suggests Changes to NTSB Certificate Review Actions

ARSA submitted comments to a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) regarding the rules of practice in air safety proceedings. ARSA’s comments propose changes that would bring balance to FAA certificate actions by giving a repair station greater ability to defend itself in the face of agency actions, when appealed to the NTSB.

ARSA suggests that the board remove language from the existing rules requiring the NTSB law judge to assume the truth of the FAA’s allegations in an “emergency” action against a certificate holder. Challenges to the agency’s determination of an emergency are all but impossible due to the requirement. Since revocations have immediate effect, certificate holders deserve the ability to challenge the basis used to reach the conclusion that a matter is an emergency.

The Association also recommends changes to the FAA’s allegations of a “lack of qualifications,” when it comes to dismissing a stale complaint. In an FAA certificate action, an accused party can have allegations dismissed if the agency fails to take any action against the accused for more than six months, unless a lack of qualifications is alleged. As a result, the FAA can avoid a dismissal for staleness by simply including an allegation of lack of qualifications. To correct this issue, ARSA suggests that the NTSB simply eliminate a lack of qualification from precluding a dismissal for staleness.

If adopted, ARSA’s comments would bring justice to the NTSB adjudication process and provide a check on government bureaucracy.

~~~ posted 4/11/12 ~~~



More from ARSA

Correct STC Oversight Problems

STC holders should take advantage of summertime opportunities to highlight FAA oversight issues to government auditors. Congress’ May 2024 reauthorization of the FAA, required the Department of Transportation’s Office of Inspector…Read More

Substitute Teaching

On May 30, ARSA Vice President of Operations Brett Levanto visited with three classes of sixth grade students at Bush Hill Elementary School in Alexandria, Virginia. Levanto was making good…Read More

Mourning with a Colleague

On May 22, a Cessna Citation 550 crashed in San Diego, California. On May 25, the San Diego Medical Examiner confirmed that among the aircraft’s passengers was Kendall Fortner, the…Read More

AMT Day – Celebrate Charlie

Charles Taylor, the Wright Brothers’ mechanic and father of aviation maintenance, was born on May 24, 1868. Now – 157 years later – we celebrate him through continued commitment to…Read More

A Future Better than Yachting in the Caribbean – 2025 Scholarship Winner Daniel Lucerne

Meet ARSA’s 2025 Scholarship winner Daniel “Danny” Lucerne of the Atlanta campus of Aviation Institute of Maintenance. Lucerne’s interest in aviation was stoked while yachting (as crew) in the Caribbean.…Read More
ARSA