Contact Us

ARSA Cautions FAA on Proposed 145 Changes

ALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA, November 29, 2012 – The Aeronautical Repair Station Association (ARSA) warned the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) against further muddying the rules governing aviation maintenance. In comments submitted Nov. 19 to the FAA’s rewrite of 14 CFR part 145, the association expressed concerns the agency’s proposed rulemaking unnecessarily complicates the regulatory framework.

While the FAA has said it wants to align regulations, current business models, and future safety management system requirements, the Association pointed out several instances where the proposed rule deviates from that purpose—

  • Absence of line maintenance rating—unlike the Canadian and European systems and current business arrangements, the FAA is not contemplating a line maintenance rating. The lack of such a rating is not conducive to business practices, in the past, now or in the future.
  • Permanent housing requirement—contract maintenance with mobility is necessary and certainly part of past, current, and future business models. To demand that a repair station have permanent “housing” belies reality and the ability of a company to ensure its system is under the control of a civil aviation authority.
  • Separating the operations specifications from the certificate—this would essentially allow the agency to unilaterally change operations specifications. The Association vehemently opposes the creation of separate operations specifications for repair stations. The FAA is merely necessitating an unnecessary burden on its own workforce and the industry.
  • Preventing certain “persons” from “controlling” a certificate—the FAA is attempting to prevent “bad actors” from “controlling” the quality of a repair station’s work. Since the FAA does not have or will not expend the resources to keep a list of “bad actors”, its workforce will have no objective criterion on which to investigation ownership of these corporate applicants. Further, ARSA pointed out that there is already a federal law prohibiting similar action (see 49 U.S.C. §§ 44726 and 44711).
  • Preventing the voluntary surrender of a certificate—the agency’s claim that it wants to prevent “bad actors” from obtaining and maintaining a certificate is laudable; its ability to prevent that action in a fair and uniform manner is nonexistent. The increase in safety that may result from the proposed requirements is well outweighed by the agency and industry burden.

The Association is also concerned about the agency’s cost estimates for implementing the proposed changes as they do not accurately reflect the true costs repair stations will bear.

Given these concerns, ARSA believes that the FAA should issue a supplemental notice of proposed rulemaking that incorporates the substantive comments made by the Association and other interested parties that will help the agency more ably meet industry needs and maintain the highest standards of safety.

ARSA’s comments are available at:

A side-by-side comparison and red-lined version of the current vs. proposed rule is available on ARSA’s website.

ARSA is an Alexandria, Virginia-based trade association that represents aviation maintenance and manufacturing companies. Founded in 1984, the association has a distinguished record of advocating for repair stations, providing regulatory compliance assistance to the industry, and representing repair stations on Capitol Hill and in the media.

Jason Langford
Director of Communications
703 739 9543

More from ARSA

MAG Change 5 – Aviation Coalition Requests Orderly Transition Period

Parts Diplomacy – Aviation Coalition Requests Orderly Transition Period
On Oct. 7, a coalition of aviation trade associations sent a letter to the FAA and EASA addressing a major issue…

Read More

Need a Break From MRO Europe? Stop By ARSA’s Tea Room

For those going to MRO Europe in London next week, be sure to stop by ARSA’s Tea Room for some light refreshments and snacks on Wednesday, Oct. 14, from 1:15…

Read More

Last Call: Audit Survey

Help the association quantify the untenable reality of non-stop, overlapping and duplicative audits on aviation maintenance providers by responding to the 2015 Audit Survey.
To begin, access the survey at: …

Read More

Hotline Highlight: 2015 SLC Sponsors

As the 2015 Strategic Leadership Conference approaches, ARSA thanks the following sponsors for their contributions. This invitation-only event for aviation maintenance executives is made possible due to the generous support…

Read More

FAA Signs New Agreements with TCCA, EASA

On Sept. 15, the FAA signed agreements with two international regulatory partners, EASA and Transport Canada (TCCA):

The FAA-EASA Bilateral Aviation Safety Agreement, Revision 5 of the Technical Implementation Procedures…

Read More