Court Sides with ARSA: Commands FAA to Show Cause
March 02, 2011
ALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA, March 2, 2011 – The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit ordered the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to explain why the court should not grant ARSA’s request forcing the agency to comply with the court’s mandate to perform a final regulatory flexibility analysis (FRFA) of its 2006 drug and alcohol rules. The FAA must respond to the court by 4:00 p.m. on March 10, 2011.
If the FAA fails to show cause, the agency will have until May 23, 2011 to complete the analysis. The court order would also stay the rules for testing of subcontractor employees who perform safety-related functions “at any tier” while the FAA carries out the review.
“This is a major victory for small business and establishes that the Regulatory Flexibility Act can have teeth,” said ARSA Executive Director Sarah MacLeod. “Today’s ruling shows that agencies cannot flaunt the law without consequence.”
In the underlying case (ARSA, et. al. v. FAA 494 F. 3d 161), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit found that the FAA failed to perform a required FRFA to determine the small business impact of its drug and alcohol testing rules. The court sided with ARSA and determined that the rules would pose a substantial burden on many small businesses; the association estimates that the FAA failed to account for as many as 22,000 small businesses.
Despite the court’s decision, the FAA ignored the mandate for more than three years. As a result, ARSA was forced to take the rare action of filing a formal request with the court to compel the FAA to fulfill its legal obligation.
A copy of the court’s order can be found here.
For more information and background on the history of the case, click here.
Contact:
Jason Langford (Jason.Langford@arsa.org)
Communications Manager
703 739 9543
###
ARSA is an Alexandria, Virginia-based trade association that represents aviation maintenance and manufacturing companies. The association has a distinguished 25-year record of advocating for repair stations and providing regulatory compliance assistance to the industry.
More from ARSA
ARSA Honors the Already Honorable
During its Annual Repair Symposium on March 19, ARSA recognized the Honorable John Goglia with the association’s Leo Weston Award for Excellence in Government Service. The award is given regularly during…Read MoreSupply Chain Throttling Aerospace Maintenance Expansion
March 23, 2026 | Categories:
Advocacy, ARSA News & Updates, ARSA Works, Aviation Policy, FAA, Legislative, Press Releases, Regulatory
On March 18, ARSA released its 2026 Global Fleet and MRO Market Report prepared by Oliver Wyman Vector. Presentation of the report’s findings was a key part of the association’s annual…Read More
