Join ARSA Ask ARSA Pay ARSA

Preventing Baseless Electronic Recordkeeping Requirements

On Feb. 26, ARSA and the Aircraft Electronics Association (AEA) jointly commented on the FAA’s Draft Advisory Circular (AC) 120-78B, “Electronic Signatures, Electronic Recordkeeping, and Electronic Manuals.” The associations acknowledged the draft AC’s “valuable technical instruction” but directed the FAA to amend language creating recordkeeping requirements inconsistent with the aviation safety rules.

“The draft AC confuses the agency’s limited authority to approve electronic recordkeeping systems of certain certificate holders with a guidance-created requirement for FAA ‘acceptance of’ those systems where there is no regulatory basis or need,” the comments said.

The joint comments overviewed the absence of language in parts 43 or 145 directing persons performing maintenance to seek FAA approval or acceptance of their recordkeeping systems. Citing the Code of Federal Regulations, statutes limiting paperwork burdens and guaranteeing the validity of digitalized records, and Department of Transportation Guidance, ARSA and AEA then described how administrative statements in the draft AC created wide latitude for FAA personnel to impose burden certificate holders without regulatory basis. Pushing back against “legislation by guidance,” through which the government imposes responsibilities not found in the plain language of the rules (and without the notice and comment burden imposed on rulemaking activities by the Administrative Procedure Act), is a fundamental tenet of the associations’ regulatory advocacy.

The submission recommend four basic amendments to ensure the guidance may be utilized by industry without imposing any additional requirements:

(1) Clarify the guidance itself creates no requirement for approval, acceptance, or authorization of an electronic recordkeeping or manual system.

(2) State that electronic recordkeeping methods utilized by repair stations (among other certificate holders) will be found acceptable provided they meet the applicable elements of 14 CFR.

(3) Eliminate language making system corrections “incumbent upon the certificate holder” when the rules didn’t require FAA approval or acceptance.

(4) Eliminate language apparently requiring FAA approval or acceptance for use of an electronic signature on a regulatorily required record.

“Advisory circulars are tools to provide compliance assistance for certificate holders,” the comments concluded. “As written, Draft AC 120-78B provides useful technical instruction for persons required or choosing to establish electronic recordkeeping systems and submit their related procedures to the FAA. The draft must be amended to avoid creating any requirement for action by certificate holders, e.g., part 145 repair stations, or the FAA.”

To read the draft AC as made available for comment, click here.

To read ARSA and AEA’s joint comments, click here.



More from ARSA

Human Factors Training Case Study – British Airways Flight 5390

ARSA’s training team analyzes the human factors contributing to maintenance failures associated with the June 10, 1990 explosive decompression of British Airways flight 5390.  The accident report stated that “as…Read More

U.S. Federal Programs Support Industrial Apprenticeships

Multiple incentive programs funded by the U.S. Department of Labor could provide resources for aerospace maintenance employers. In July, the government awarded nearly $162 million to five organizations to lead…Read More

Final Rule Alleviates “Current Data” Burden

On Nov. 10, the Federal Register published the FAA’s final rule “Inspection Programs for Single-Engine Turbine-Powered Airplanes and Unmanned Aircraft; and Miscellaneous Maintenance-Related Updates.” Included in those “miscellaneous updates” are: (1) Removal…Read More

Repair Station Radio Podcast – “Swimming the Current”

The association’s team returns for a full 20 minutes (and a few seconds) to talk about the “miscellaneous maintenance updates” in a recently issued FAA Final Rule removing the “current”…Read More

President McHugh Finds Fresh Faces and Familiarity on ARSA Board

On Oct. 30, ARSA’s Board of Directors gathered for its annual meeting in Arlington, Virginia. The body pivoted from the previous day’s collaborative roundtable discussions into reviewing the association’s work…Read More
ARSA