Join ARSA Ask ARSA Pay ARSA

Request for Clarification of FAA D&A Testing Rules

On April 1, 2010, ARSA again requested clarification of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) anti-drug and alcohol rules. This time, ARSA seeks to resolve uncertainty surrounding an employee’s permanent disqualification from service and the implications of a “shy bladder” refusal to test for individuals in a follow-up testing program.

In plain terms, an employee with two verified positive drug tests is permanently barred from performing safety-sensitive duties for any employer (14 CFR § 120.111(e)(1)); essentially, two strikes and you’re out. Before allowing a covered employee to return to safety-sensitive work after testing positive for drugs (first strike), an employer must comply with follow-up testing requirements (14 CFR § 120.109). If, during the follow-up tests, the employee cannot provide an adequate sample for testing—referred to as a “shy bladder”—it is considered a refusal to test if the circumstance is not the result of a medical condition (49 CFR §§ 40.193(d)(2) and 40.191(a)(5)).

Although the terms “refusal to submit to drug test” and “verified positive drug test result” are separately defined (14 CFR § 120.7), questions have arisen when the “refusal” occurs during the course of follow-up testing; that a refusal in this context is a second strike.

Compounding the issue, questions crop up as to the handling of the individual if such a refusal is not a second strike. If the person holds an FAA certificate under parts 61, 63 or 65, the drug and alcohol rules provide specific consequences for a refusal to test (14 CFR §§ 120.11, 120.13 and 120.15). However, for safety-sensitive employees not certificated by the FAA, an employer is instructed to direct the individual to the follow-up testing program; seemingly, such persons could repeatedly “refuse to test” and simply re-start the follow-up program after each occurrence.



More from ARSA

President McHugh Finds Fresh Faces and Familiarity on ARSA Board

On Oct. 30, ARSA’s Board of Directors gathered for its annual meeting in Arlington, Virginia. The body pivoted from the previous day’s collaborative roundtable discussions into reviewing the association’s work…Read More

“Doing Big Things with Big Rocks”

On Oct. 29, ARSA and its Board of Directors hosted representatives from its enterprise member companies, allied organizations, and key government officials for its Annual Leadership Roundtables. The series of…Read More

This is Us

Based on an overview provided by ARSA Director Art Smith, the association produced this 50 second commercial for its work and its industry. Members are encouraged to go to the…Read More

On Demand SMS Training – ERPs

Four Safety Management Systems Training Sessions are now available through ARSA’s training program for registration and immediate on-demand viewing. The trainings were co-administered by ARSA and the Aircraft Electronics Association…Read More

On Demand Training – HazMat Determinations

On Oct. 14, ARSA presented an online training session introducing the key definitions in 49 CFR tied to hazardous materials requirements for maintenance providers in 14 CFR. The level 1…Read More
ARSA